Case Number CR 94-928 filed at this court on 08/30/1994
Case Caption:
DAMIEN WAYNE ECHOLS
CHARLES JASON BALDWIN
V
STATE OF ARKANSAS
Damien Wayne Echols (ACTIVE) Appellant's counsel:
E. Alvin Schay - LEAD
Deborah Ruth Sallings - LEAD
William Scott Davidson - COURT-APP
Val Parham Price - COURT-APP
Damien Wayne Echols - COURT-APP
Edward A Mallett - LEAD
Robert C Owen - LEAD
Dennis P Riordan - LEAD
Donald M Horgan - LEAD
Theresa A Gibbons - LEAD
Charles Jason Baldwin (ACTIVE) Appellant's counsel:
Joseph Blake Hendrix Jr - LEAD
Paul N. Ford - COURT-APP
George R. Wadley Jr - COURT-APP
Conviction Information:
Convicted of: ?????????
Sentence: 0- 0- 0 (yyy-mm-ddd)
Sentence Type ?????????
State Of Arkansas (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:
Attorney General - LEAD
J. Winston Bryant - COURT-APP
Trial Court: Craighead
Craighead Circuit, Western District
Trial Court Number: CR93-450 & CR93-450A
Trial Judge: Charles David Burnett
------- EVENT LISTING --------
06/09/2008 Response to Petition to Proceed in the Trial
Appellee's Attorney - Attorney General
Response to petition to proceed in the trial court with a writ of error coram nobis.
05/29/2008 Petition to Proceed in the Trial Court with a Action = awaiting action
Appellant's Attorney - Joseph Blake Hendrix Jr
Petition to proceed in the trial court with a writ of error coram nobis.
02/24/2005 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 02/17/05
Appellant's Attorney - Donald Horgan
02/24/2005 Mandate to Governor, Clerk & AG
02/24/2005 Supplemental Opinion Issued
ACTION = OTHER OPINION ACTION (MISC)
Opinion Date - 02/24/05 Consist of 0 pages,
Cite Number - Publish - yes
Thomas Glaze -- WRITING
Petition for Rehearing Denied; Supplemental Opinion Issued.
Petition for rehearing denied; supplemental opinion issued.
02/14/2005 Response to Petition for Rehearing - State Of Appellee's Attorney - Attorney General
02/07/2005 Petition for Rehearing - Damien Wayne Echols
Submitted to the court on - 02/17/05
Action = DENIED on 02/24/05
Appellant's Attorney - Donald Horgan
Petition for rehearing denied; supplemental opinion issued.
01/20/2005 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 01/13/05
Appellant's Attorney - Dennis Riordan
01/20/2005 Majority Opinion Rendered
ACTION = OTHER OPINION ACTION (MISC)
Opinion Date - 01/20/05 Consist of 0 pages,
Cite Number - Publish - yes
Thomas Glaze -- WRITING
Motion Denied. Imber, J., concurs.
Petitioner's Motion to Recall the Mandate and to Reinvest Jurisdiction in the Trial Court to Consider Petition for Writ of Error Coram Nobis or for Other Extraordinary Relief. Motion Denied. Imber, J., concurs.
01/20/2005 Opinion Panel
Thomas Glaze -- WRITING
01/13/2005 Supreme Court Votesheet Issued
01/13/2005 Case Submitted
Submitted to the court on - 01/13/05
12/20/2004 Reply to Response to Motion to Recall Mandate
Appellant's Attorney - Dennis Riordan
12/13/2004 Response to Motion to Recall the Mandate - St
Appellee's Attorney - Attorney General
Response to motion to recall the mandate and to reinvest jurisdiction in the circuit court to consider petition for writ of error coram nobis or for other extraordinary relief.
12/02/2004 Response Time Commenced on Motion to Recall Man t
This event was tickled for 12/13/04
Appellee's Attorney - Attorney General
12/02/2004 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Appellant's Attorney - Dennis Riordan
12/02/2004 Motion to File Exhibits Under Seal - Damien W
Submitted to the court on - 01/13/05
Action = GRANTED on 01/20/05
Appellant's Attorney - Dennis Riordan
Petitioner's motion to file under seal certain exhibits proffered in support of motion to recall the mandate and to reinvest jurisdiction in the trial court to consider petition for writ of error coram nobis and other extraordinary relief. Motion granted.
12/02/2004 Motion to Recall the Mandate - Damien Wayne E
Action = OTHER on 12/02/04
Appellant's Attorney - Dennis Riordan
Petitioner's motion to recall the mandate and to reinvest jurisdiction in the trial court to consider petition for writ of error coram nobis or for other extraordinary relief. Motion to be submitted as a case. State's response to petitioner's motion due on December 13, 2004; reply to response due 5 days after.
11/30/2004 Tendered Response to Motion to Recall Mandate
Appellee's Attorney - Attorney General
10/29/2004 UNDER SEAL - ONE ENVELOPE EXHIBITS
(tendered with motion to file exhibits under seal)
10/29/2004 Tendered Motion to File Exhibits Under Seal
Tendered petitioner's motion to file under seal certain exhibits proffered in support of motion to recall the mandate and to reinvest jurisdiction in the trial court to consider petition for writ of error coram nobis and other extraordinary relief.
(pending ruling on motion to practice by comity)
10/29/2004 Tendered Motion to Recall Mandate
Tendered motion to recall the mandate and to reinvest jurisdiction in the trial court to consider petition for writ of error coram nobis or for other extraordinary relief.
(pending ruling on motion to practice by comity).
10/21/2004 Motion to Practice by Comity
Submitted to the court on - 11/04/04
Motion of Dennis P. Riordan, Donald M. Horgan, and Theresa A. Gibbons for permission to practice by comity.
10-19-04. Received affidavits and certificates of good standing on Dennis P. Riordan, Donald M. Horgan and Theresa A. Gibbons.
12-02-04. Motion of Dennis P. Riordan, Donald M. Horgan,and Theresa A. Gibbons for permission to practice by comity is granted.
01/12/2004 Amended Motion for Attorney's Fees - Damien W
Action = awaiting action
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
11/13/2003 Mandate to Clerk
11/13/2003 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 11/06/03
Appellant's Attorney - Robert Owen
11/06/2003 Response to Rehearing - State Of Arkansas
Appellee's Attorney - Attorney General
10/30/2003 Petition for Rehearing - Damien Wayne Echols
Submitted to the court on - 11/06/03
Action = DENIED on 11/13/03
Appellant's Attorney - Robert Owen
Petition for rehearing is denied.
10/16/2003 Majority Opinion Rendered
ACTION = WRIT DENIED
Opinion Date - 10/16/03 Consist of 0 pages, Cite Number - Publish - yes
Donald Corbin -- WRITING
Imber, J., concurs.
Annabelle Clinton Imber -- WRITING
Concurs.
10/16/2003 Opinion Panel
Donald Corbin -- WRITING
Annabelle Clinton Imber -- WRITING
10/02/2003 Case Submitted - Orally Argued
10/02/2003 Supreme Court Oral Argument Issued for
REGULAR DOCKET scheduled for 10/02/03 at A.M. - ORAL Argument.
10/02/2003 Supreme Court Votesheet Issued
10/01/2003 Additional Case(s) Cited for Oral Argument -
Appellant's Attorney - Robert Owen
10/01/2003 Additional Case(s) Cited for Oral Argument -
Appellee's Attorney - Attorney General
06/19/2003 70 Day Stay Granted; Final Extension
This event was tickled for 08/28/03
06/19/2003 Per Curiam Order
Action = FINALEXT on 06/19/03
Motion to extend stay of proceedings. Granted 70 days; final extension. See per curiam this date. Corbin, J., not participating.
06/19/2003 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 06/12/03
Appellant's Attorney - Robert Owen
05/28/2003 Motion to Extend Stay of Proceedigs Until Com
Submitted to the court on - 06/12/03
Action = FINALEXT on 06/19/03
Appellant's Attorney - Robert Owen
Motion to extend stay of proceedings. Granted 70 days; final extension. See per curiam this date. Corbin, J., not participating.
02/28/2003 90-Day Stay Granted
This event was tickled for 05/29/03
02/28/2003 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 02/20/03
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
02/06/2003 Motion for 90-Day Extension of Stay of Procee
Submitted to the court on - 02/20/03
Action = GRANTED on 02/28/03
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
Motion for 90-day extension of stay of proceedings is granted.
11/14/2002 90 Day Stay of Proceedings
This event was tickled for 02/12/03
11/14/2002 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 11/07/02
Appellant's Attorney - Robert Owen
11/04/2002 Unopposed Motion for 90 Day Extension of Stay
Submitted to the court on - 11/07/02
Action = GRANTED on 11/14/02
Appellant's Attorney - Robert Owen
Unopposed motion for 90-day extension of stay of proceedings is granted.
09/12/2002 By Per Curiam Order -Error Coram Nobis to be
By per curiam order of September 12, 2002 - error coram nobis petition currently filed in CR99-1060 - to be filed under direct-appeal case number, CR94-928.
CR94-928. Petition for writ of error coram nobis and CR99-1060 - Rule 37 petition to be submitted and heard on the same date.
11/29/2001 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
11/08/2001 Statement in Compliance with Rule XIV
Submitted to the court on - 11/29/01
Appellant's Attorney - Robert Owen
Counsel's statement in compliance with Rule XIV, rules governing admission to the bar of Arkansas. Noted.
11/01/2001 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 10/18/01
Appellant's Attorney - Robert Owen
11/01/2001 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 10/25/01
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
11/01/2001 Printed Reply Brief Filed Damien Wayne Echol
WRIT OF ERROR CORAM NOBIS
10/17/2001 Response to Motion to Appear for Oral Argumen
Appellee's Attorney - Attorney General
10/15/2001 Motion for Leave to Appear for Oral Argument
Submitted to the court on - 10/18/01
Action = GRANTED on 11/01/01
Appellant's Attorney - Robert Owen
Motion of Robert C. Owen to appear for oral argument only on pending coram nobis matter and motion to set oral argument. Motion granted; attorney Owen to file written statement in complliance with Rule 14 Governing Admission to the Bar. Clerk to set oral argument after compliance.
10/11/2001 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 10/04/01
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
10/10/2001 Motion for Reconsideration - Damien Wayne Ech
Submitted to the court on - 10/25/01
Action = GRANTED on 11/01/01
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
Appellant's motion to reconsider denial of leave to file reply brief received one day late is granted.
09/21/2001 Motion for Leave to Appear for Oral Argument
Submitted to the court on - 10/04/01
Action = DENIED on 10/11/01
Appellant's Attorney - Edward Mallett
Motion for leave to appear for oral argument only on pending coram nobis matter and to set oral argument is denied.
07/30/2001 Brief Filed Timely - State Of Arkansas
State Of Arkansas - brief due on xx/xx/xxxx
WRIT OF ERROR CORAM NOBIS
06/14/2001 Printed Brief Filed Timely - Damien Wayne Ec
Damien Wayne Echols - brief due on 10/10/94
WRIT OF ERROR CORAM NOBIS
06/07/2001 CORRECTED BRIEF DUE 6-14-2001
06/07/2001 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 05/31/01
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
05/17/2001 Brief Tendered - Damien Wayne. Echols
This event was tickled for 05/24/01
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
Damien Wayne Echols - brief due on 05/24/01
05/17/2001 Motion to Supplement Exhibits in Support of E
Action = GRANTED on 05/31/01
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
Appellant's motion to supplement exhibits in support of petition for writ of error coram nobis is granted.
(Exhibit KK in Support of Petition for writ of error coram nobis.)
05/17/2001 Motion to File Enlarged Brief - Damien Wayne
Submitted to the court on - 05/31/01
Action = DENIED on 06/07/01
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
Appellant's motion to file enlarged brief is denied. See Pemberton v. State, 291 Ark. 198 (1987).
04/19/2001 Appellant's Brief on Petitions Due 5-17-01
04/11/2001 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Fil
Action = GRANTED on 04/19/01
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
Unopposed motion for extension of time to file brief (on petitions) is granted.
4-19-01. Appellant's brief (on briefing of petitions) due 5-17-02.
03/08/2001 Briefing Commenced on Petitions - Damien Wayne. c
This event was tickled for 04/17/01
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
Damien Wayne Echols - brief due on 04/17/01
03/08/2001 Petitions to be submitted as a case.
Appellant's petition to reinvest jurisdiction in circuit court and petition for writ of error coram nobis - to be submitted as a case. See order of 3-8-01.
03/06/2001 Response to Motion to Reinvest Jurisdiction i
Appellee's Attorney - Attorney General
Response to motion to reinvest jurisdiction in circuit court.
02/27/2001 Petition To Reinvest Jurisdiction in Circuit
Action = OTHER on 03/08/01
Appellant's Attorney - E. Alvin Schay
Petition to reinvest jurisdiction in circuit court to consider petition for writ of error coram nobis or, in the alternative, to consider petition for writ of error com nobis and writ of audita querela. Petition to be submitted as a case.
06/02/1997 Mandate to Clerk
Petition for writ of certiorari denied. Mandate to Clerk
03/31/1997 Notice of Filing Petition in U. S. Supreme Court
5-30-97. Order from U. S. Supreme Court denying certiorari. Filed.
03/25/1997 Attorney's Fees and Costs - Supreme Court
03/24/1997 Formal Orders - Supreme Court
03/24/1997 Formal Orders - Supreme Court
03/03/1997 Petition (Miscellaneous)
Submitted to the court on - 03/17/97
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
Petition to Recall Mandate 3-10-97. Appellee's response. Served. 3-24-97. Appellant's motion to recall mandate is granted for ninety days.
01/10/1997 Motion for Attorney's Fees
Submitted to the court on - 02/20/97
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
Val P. Price, Scott Davidson, Paul N. Ford and George R. Wadley, Jr. allowed $10,000.00 in attorney's fees and $745.77 in costs for a total of $10,745.77.
01/10/1997 Mandate to Clerk
12/31/1996 Front Sheets - West
12/30/1996 Front Sheets - Mead
12/23/1996 ACTION/OPINION Information
ROBERT H. DUDLEY, Writing rendered on 12/23/96 Published -
Y AFF
12/23/1996 Panel Information
ROBERT H. DUDLEY SC Judge, Writing
12/13/1996 Motion for Attorney's Fees
Submitted to the court on - 02/20/97
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
Val P. Price, Scott Davidson, Paul N. Ford, George R. Wadley, Jr., allowed $10,000.00 in attorney's fees and $745.77 in costs for a total of $10,745.77. 3-27-97. Invoice received.
12/02/1996 Hearing Information
Submitted on - 12/02/96
Hearing type:REGULAR /
Argument type:ORAL
12/02/1996 Supreme Court Oral Argument Issued for
12/02/1996 Supreme Court Votesheet Issued
11/27/1996 Stipulation of Parties to Supplement the Record
11/25/1996 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
11/20/1996 Motion (Miscellaneous)
Submitted to the court on - 11/20/96
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
Motion for Additional Time To Present Oral Argument. Served. 11-25-96. Each appellant granted twenty minutes for oral argument.
11/18/1996 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
11/15/1996 Motion (Miscellaneous)
Submitted to the court on - 11/18/96
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
Motion for Additional Time to Present Oral Argument. Served. 11-25-96. Each appellant granted twenty minutes for oral argument.
11/14/1996 Motion (Miscellaneous)
Submitted to the court on - 11/18/96
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
Motion for Additional Time to Present Oral Argument. Served. 11-25-96. Each appellant granted twenty minutes for oral argument.
11/01/1996 Motion to Reschedule Oral Argument
Submitted to the court on - 11/11/96
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
09/11/1996 Appellant's Reply Brief (Printed) Filed
This event was tickled for 10/11/96
The event was complied with on 10/11/96
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
09/09/1996 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
07/01/1996 Motion to File Enlarged Brief
Submitted to the court on - 09/03/96
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
Motion to file enlarged reply brief. Served. 9-9-96. Appellant's motion to file enlarged reply brief is granted.
07/01/1996 Reply Brief Tendered
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
05/22/1996 Motion for Extension to File Brief
This event was tickled for 07/03/96
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
05/16/1996 Noted for Oral Argument
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
05/14/1996 Appellee's Brief Filed
This event was tickled for 05/29/96
The event was complied with on 05/29/96
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
04/23/1996 Supplemental Record Filed
This record filed on hearing of competency.
04/23/1996 Order of Circuit Court
Two volumes record filed in order of compentency.
02/01/1996 Appellant's Reply Brief (Printed) Filed
This event was tickled for 03/02/96
The event was complied with on 03/02/96
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
01/16/1996 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
01/16/1996 Appellant's Reply Brief (Typed) Filed
This event was tickled for 02/15/96
The event was complied with on 02/15/96
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
01/08/1996 ACTION/OPINION Information
0, Writing rendered on 01/08/96Published - Y MO/GRANTED
01/08/1996 Front Sheets - Mead
01/08/1996 Formal Orders - Supreme Court
01/03/1996 Noted for Oral Argument
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
12/29/1995 Motion to File Enlarged Brief
Submitted to the court on - 01/08/96
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
(for enlarged reply brief) 1-16-96. Appellant's motion to file enlarged reply brief is granted.
12/29/1995 Reply Brief Tendered
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
Enlarged.
12/15/1995 Motion for Extension to File Brief
This event was tickled for 12/29/95
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
12/06/1995 Motion (Miscellaneous)
Submitted to the court on - 12/18/95
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
Motion To Withdraw Pro Se Request To Waive Death Penalty Issues on Appeal. Served. 12-15-95. Response to motion to withdraw request to waive death penalty issues on appeal. Served. 1-8-96. Appellant's motion to withdraw pro se request to waive death penalty issue on appeal is granted.
See per curiam this date.
12/04/1995 Motion for Extension to File Brief
This event was tickled for 12/15/95
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
11/21/1995 Supplemental Brief Filed
This event was tickled for 12/21/95
The event was complied with on 12/21/95
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
11/20/1995 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
10/30/1995 Motion to File Enlarged Brief
Submitted to the court on - 11/13/95
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
11-20-95. Appellee's motion to file enlarged brief is granted.
10/30/1995 Supplemental Brief Tendered
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
10/12/1995 Motion for Extension to File Brief
This event was tickled for 10/29/95
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
09/12/1995 Motion for Extension to File Brief
This event was tickled for 10/22/95
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
09/12/1995 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
07/21/1995 Front Sheets - Mead
07/19/1995 Motion to Stay Brief Time
Submitted to the court on - 09/05/95
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
pending determination of appellant Echols' competency to waive death penalty issues. Served. 8-2-95. Tendered - Reply to mtoion to stay brief time pending determination of appellant, Echols' competency to waive death penalty issues. Served. 9-11-95. Appellee's motion to stay brief time pending determination of appellant Echols' competency to waive death-penalty issues is granted as to Echols and denied as to Baldwin.
07/17/1995 Formal Orders - Supreme Court
07/12/1995 Appellant's Brief (Printed) Filed
This event was tickled for 08/11/95
The event was complied with on 08/11/95
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
07/12/1995 Appellant's Brief (Printed) Filed
This event was tickled for 08/11/95
The event was complied with on 08/11/95
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
06/29/1995 Motion for Extension to File Brief
This event was tickled for 09/22/95
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
06/27/1995 Motion (Miscellaneous)
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
Pro se motion to limit appeal to issues of conviction, not the sentence. Served. 7-17-95. Pro se motion to limit appeal. Remanded See per curiam this date. 4-23-96. Two volumes supp. record filed in competence hearing.
06/19/1995 Appellant's Brief (Typed) Filed
This event was tickled for 07/19/95
The event was complied with on 07/19/95
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
06/11/1995 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
06/05/1995 Appellant's Brief (Typed) Filed
This event was tickled for 07/05/95
The event was complied with on 07/05/95
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
05/31/1995 Motion to File Enlarged Brief
Submitted to the court on - 06/05/95
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
Appellant's motion to file enlarged brief. Granted 65 pages. (Brief due 6-19-95)
05/31/1995 Appellant's Brief Tendered
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
Enlarged.
05/31/1995 Appellant's Brief Tendered
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
Enlarged.
05/30/1995 Supplemental Record Filed
One envelope exhibits
05/30/1995 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
05/30/1995 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
05/08/1995 Motion for Extension to File Brief
This event was tickled for 05/31/95
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
05/08/1995 Motion (Miscellaneous)
Submitted to the court on - 05/22/95
Appellant's Attorney - Paul N. Ford
Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief and to File Enlarged Brief. Served. 5-30-95. Appellant's motion to file enlarged brief Appellant granted leave to file 65 page brief. Extension of time granted.
03/06/1995 Motion for Extension to File Brief
This event was tickled for 05/09/95
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
George Wadley extension of time is moot.
01/05/1995 Motion for Extension to File Brief
This event was tickled for 03/10/95
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
09/27/1994 Motion for Extension to File Brief
This event was tickled for 01/09/95
Appellant's Attorney - William Scott Davidson
08/30/1994 Transcript Filed
4 manila envelopes - in records section storage - 1 envelope exhibits supplemented 5-30-95. Also in records storage.
08/30/1994 Print Case Card
08/30/1994 Criminal Notice of Transcript Filed
This event was tickled for 10/09/94
The event was complied with on 10/09/94
08/30/1994 Print Case Card
08/30/1994 Briefing Commenced - Damien Wayne Echols
Damien Wayne Echols - brief due on 08/30/94
08/30/1994 Briefing Commenced - Charles Jason Baldwin
Charles Jason Baldwin - brief due on 08/30/94
01/01/1900 Exhibit(s) Released to Atty. - See Remarks
3 envelopes of exhibits
01/01/1900 Per Curiam Order
Appellant's motion to withdraw pro se request to waive death penalty issue on appeal is granted.
01/01/1900 AS400 event description not available
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
19 Vol.
01/01/1900 Transcript Checkout by Atty. of Record
Appellee's Attorney - J. Winston Bryant
19, Vol.
