IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF
CRAIGHEAD COUNTY, ARKANSAS
STATE OF ARKANSAS PLAINTIFF
VS NO. CR
93-450
CHARLES JASON BALDWIN DEFENDANT
MOTION FOR RECUSAL
COMES NOW the Defendant,
Charles Jason Baldwln, by and through his attorneys, Paul N. Ford and George R.
Wadley, Jr., and for his Motion herein, for cause, states:
1. That on the 19th day of March, 1994, the Defendant
was sentenced, and a judgment of conviction was imposed, on three counts of
capital murder.
2. That within ten (10) days of said filing, the
Defendant filed a Motion for a New Trial herein alleging, inter alia, that the
Prosecutors were guilty of misconduct by participation in an ex parte
conversation with the Honorable Judge David Burnett.
3. That the Defendant would request that the trial
Court, the Honorable Judge David Burnett, recuse in this matter so an impartial
Court could determine whether or not the prosecution was guilty of misconduct
in said ex parte conversation.
4. That the Arkansas Rules of Evidence prohibit a
Judge from being a witness at trial. That in order to fully develop the record
on the Defendant's Motion for New Trial, it would be necessary to call the
Honorable Judge David Burnett as a witness in order to determine what he said
to the Prosecuting Attorneys during said ex parte conversation. That it would
be insufficient to allow the Prosecutors themselves to be called as a witness
as the words of the Court would be inadmissible as hearsay.
WHEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, the
Defendant, Charles Jason Baldwin, prays that this Court recuse itself for
purposes of determination of the Motion for New Trial filed herein by the
Defendant, Charles Jason Baldwin, and for any and all other just and proper
relief to which the Defendant may show himself entitled.
Respectfully submitted,
By: Paul N. Ford [signed]
PAUL N. FORD
STATE BAR NO. 87060
REES LAW FIRM
702 N. Missouri
West Memphis, AR 72301
(501) 735-6223
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, PAUL N. FORD, hereby certify that I have served a copy of the foregoing
instrument or pleading upon opposing counsel, as listed below, by placing same
properly addressed in the mail with sufficient postage to ensure delivery this 6th
day of April, 1994.
Mr. John N. Fogleman
P.O. Box 1666
West Memphis, AR 72301
Mr. Val Price
P.O. Box 3072
Jonesboro, AR 72403
Honorable Judge David Burnett
P.0.Box 702
Osceola, AR 72370
BY: Paul N. Ford [signed]
PAUL N. FORD
Stamped:
Filed
April 7 1994 @ 3:05 p.m.
Pat Fleetwood
Circuit& Chancery Court Clerk